Pirate's Booty Aged White Cheddar: Nutrition & Labelgrade C+ (68/100)
C+ 68 / 100 — A baked (never fried) corn-and-rice puff with a short, recognizable label and real aged cheddar — cleaner than most cheese-flavored snacks, and zero sugar. But it's a carb snack, not a protein: 19g of carbs and only 2g of protein per ounce. The C+ reflects a decent ingredient panel and zero sugar offset by the per-100g sodium and the near-absent protein.
🛒 Buy on Amazon →The short answer
Pirate’s Booty Aged White Cheddar delivers 2 g of protein and 130 calories per 1 oz (28 g) serving (USDA FDC 1861633) — and 19 g of that ounce is carbohydrate. That ratio settles the question of what this is: a cheese-flavored corn-and-rice puff, not a protein. What it does well is be a cleaner cheese puff. It’s baked rather than fried (5 g of fat per ounce, only 1 g saturated, versus the ~10 g in fried cheese curls), it carries zero sugar, and the label is five recognizable items — corn meal, rice, oil, real aged cheddar, black pepper — with no dyes or artificial sweeteners. It earns a C+ (68 / 100): a strong ingredient panel and a perfect sugar score, held down by sodium density and near-zero protein. Buy it as a no-junk swap for neon cheese puffs, and eat it as the snack it is.
Why the C+
| Dimension | Grade | Score | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protein density | C | 61 / 100 | ~7 g per 100 g — low. This is a starch puff; the cheddar is seasoning, not a protein source |
| Ingredient quality | B+ | 80 / 100 | Five recognizable items: corn meal, rice, oil, real aged cheddar, black pepper. No dyes, no artificial sweeteners |
| Saturated fat load | B | 77 / 100 | 1 g per ounce — low, the payoff of baking instead of frying |
| Sugar load | A+ | 100 / 100 | 0 g — no added sugar, unusual for a flavored snack |
| Sodium load | D | 47 / 100 | 140 mg per ounce (~500 mg per 100 g) — fine for one serving, but the bag climbs fast |
| Fiber | F | 30 / 100 | 0 g — typical for a puffed corn-and-rice snack |
The grade is an honest split. Two dimensions are genuinely good — the ingredient panel and the zero sugar are better than almost anything else in the cheese-snack aisle — and two are genuinely weak. The sodium D is the kind of thing a single ounce hides and a finished bag does not: at ~500 mg per 100 g, polishing off the 6 oz bag puts you near 3,000 mg of sodium, past a full day’s limit. And the protein “C” isn’t a formula quirk; it’s the product. A puff made of corn meal and rice has the macros of corn meal and rice, regardless of how good the cheddar dust tastes.
The “cheddar” is the flavor, not the food
It’s worth being precise about where the cheese sits, because the name does a lot of work. Aged cheddar cheese is the fourth ingredient — after the corn meal, the rice, and the oil — and it’s a seasoning coat, not a structural ingredient. That ordering is the whole story of the nutrition label: the puff is starch, and the cheddar is the reason you reach for it. The flip side is fair to Pirate’s Booty: it uses real cultured-milk cheddar (with whey and buttermilk) rather than the cheese powder and artificial color that define most of the category, which is exactly why it grades a B+ on ingredients instead of a C. You’re getting authentic cheddar flavor on a near-zero-protein base — a good-tasting snack honestly built, just not a nutritious one.
What you’re actually buying: the texture
If protein isn’t the draw, what is? The airy, melt-on-the-tongue baked puff and a label parents can read without flinching. That combination is the genuine appeal here. The baking shows up in the macros as the one real nutritional win — 1 g of saturated fat and 5 g of fat total per ounce, both low for the format — and in the eating experience as a lighter, less greasy crunch than a fried curl. It’s also why this is a fixture in kids’ lunchboxes: a recognizable five-ingredient label, no dyes, and a texture small hands like. Read the page for what it is and the C+ makes sense — a well-made snack that’s honest about being a snack, not a food masquerading as nutrition.
How it compares
Stacked against the two snacks we’ve scored alongside it, Pirate’s Booty lands in the middle — cleaner than most of the aisle, but out-nutritioned per gram by both.
| Product | Protein / 100 g | Calories | Fiber | Sodium | Labelgrade |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pirate’s Booty White Cheddar (this product) | ~7 g | 130 / oz | 0 g | 140 mg / oz | C+ (68) |
| Hippeas Vegan White Cheddar | ~14 g | 60 / 14 g | ~1 g | 110 mg / 14 g | B- (73) |
| SkinnyPop Original Popcorn | ~11 g | 100 / 18 g | 2 g | 45 mg / 18 g | B+ (80) |
Two specific gaps stand out. Hippeas (FDC 2670667) builds its puff on chickpea and yellow-pea flour, which roughly doubles the protein per 100 g and adds a gram of fiber Pirate’s Booty doesn’t have — though it trades away real dairy cheddar to do it. SkinnyPop (FDC 1877548) is the cleanest of the three: a three-ingredient whole-grain popcorn with 2 g of fiber per bag and barely a third of the sodium density. Where Pirate’s Booty wins is squarely on flavor — actual aged cheddar versus Hippeas’s yeast-extract “cheese” and SkinnyPop’s plain salt. None of these is a protein food; the real contest is which savory crunch is built best, and Pirate’s Booty is a credible, if not the strongest, pick.
Ingredients
Corn meal and rice form the puff; a blend of sunflower, expeller-pressed canola, or corn oil carries the baking; real aged cheddar cheese (cultured milk, salt, enzymes, whey, buttermilk) is the seasoning; black pepper rounds it out. Five recognizable components, no dyes, no artificial sweeteners. (Verbatim from the USDA Branded Foods entry, FDC 1861633: corn meal, rice, contains one or more of the following: sunflower, expeller pressed canola or corn oil, aged cheddar cheese [cultured milk, salt, enzymes, whey, buttermilk], black pepper.)
Where to buy
Affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. The Labelgrade score is independent of affiliate relationships. More.
🔬 Compare this product side-by-side with any other →
Quick Facts
Per serving · 1 oz (28 g)
Full nutrition facts
| Nutrient | Per Serving (1 oz (28 g)) |
|---|---|
| Calories | 130 |
| Protein | 2g |
| Total Fat | 5g |
| Saturated Fat | 1g |
| Trans Fat | 0g |
| Total Carbohydrates | 19g |
| Dietary Fiber | 0g |
| Total Sugars | 0g |
| Sodium | 140mg |
| Cholesterol | 0mg |
| Calcium | 19.9mg |
| Iron | 0mg |
Scope: This page applies specifically to Pirate's Booty Aged White Cheddar Puffs (6 oz (170 g) bag) · UPC 015665771455. Other sizes, flavors, or formulations may differ.
How this fits each diet
Each score is computed from the same USDA nutrition + ingredient data, against the published rules of each diet. They tell you "does this food fit this diet" — not whether the diet is right for you.
contains animal-derived ingredients
contains no listed meat or fish
no wheat, barley, rye, or malt detected in USDA ingredient list
Frequently Asked Questions
How much protein is in Pirate's Booty Aged White Cheddar?
2 g per 1 oz (28 g) serving (USDA FDC 1861633) — about 7 g per 100 g. Set that against 19 g of carbohydrate in the same ounce and the verdict is plain: this is a cheese-flavored corn-and-rice puff, not a protein source. The whole 6 oz bag holds roughly 12 g of protein and over 110 g of carbs.
Where does the 'aged white cheddar' protein come from — is the cheese the protein?
No. Real aged cheddar (cultured milk, salt, enzymes, whey, buttermilk) is the fourth ingredient, dusted on as seasoning — it's there for flavor, not macros. The 2 g of protein per ounce comes mostly from the corn meal and rice that make up the puff itself. The cheese is what makes it taste good; it isn't what makes it food.
Is Pirate's Booty healthier than regular cheese puffs?
On the label, modestly. It's baked rather than fried, so 5 g of fat per ounce and only 1 g of it saturated — versus roughly 10 g total in fried cheese curls — plus zero sugar and a five-item ingredient list with real cheddar instead of cheese powder and dyes. But it's still 130 calories of starch per ounce, and the sodium grades a D by density. 'Better cheese puff' is the honest frame, not 'health food.'
Why only a C+ if the ingredients are clean?
Labelgrade scores six things, and a clean panel is only one of them. Pirate's Booty earns a B+ on ingredients and a perfect A+ on sugar, but the score is dragged down by a D on sodium (140 mg per ounce, ~500 mg per 100 g) and a C on protein density (~7 g per 100 g). Two strong dimensions and two weak ones average to a C+.
Does it contain artificial sweeteners or dyes?
No. The USDA ingredient list has no artificial sweeteners and no artificial colors — the pale, off-white look is just the aged cheddar, not the neon orange of dyed cheese snacks. That clean panel is the brand's main selling point.
Is it gluten-free?
Yes — the puff is built from corn meal and rice, not wheat, and Pirate's Booty labels it gluten-free. If you have celiac disease or a serious sensitivity, confirm against the actual bag, since lines and flavors can differ.
Pirate's Booty or Hippeas — which is the better-built puff?
Per equal weight, Hippeas Vegan White Cheddar edges it: its chickpea-and-pea base puts protein near 14 g per 100 g (about double Pirate's Booty's ~7 g) and adds a gram of real fiber, where Pirate's Booty has none (FDC 2670667). Pirate's Booty counters with real dairy cheddar and fewer milligrams of sodium per serving. Neither is a protein food; Hippeas is the marginally more nutritious crunch, Pirate's Booty the more cheese-forward one.